Should I use 'historic' or 'historical' to describe an old building in my essay?
I'm writing an essay about famous landmarks in my city, and I'm a bit confused about when to use 'historic' versus 'historical.' For example, should I say, 'This is a historic building,' or 'This is a historical building'? I've seen both used in articles and textbooks, but I can't figure out which one is more appropriate for my context.
In another sentence, I'm describing an event: 'The museum hosts historical exhibits every summer.' Does that sound right, or should it be 'historic exhibits'? If anyone can help clarify the difference with these examples, I'd really appreciate it!
Context:
Audience: Intermediate ESL students writing academic essays. Style: formal, academic.
What to Know
| What to Know | Why It Matters | Example | Quick Check |
|---|---|---|---|
| If you want to show that a building played an important role in history, use "historic" . | If you mean it is simply from the past, use "historical" . | If you mean it is simply from the past, use "historical" . | Does "'historic'" match my intended meaning and tone here? |
| Avoid "'historic'" in literal contexts or when the intended meaning is unclear. | This keeps the idiom natural and avoids overly literal wording. | In literal situations, use direct wording instead of the idiom. | Would this idiom sound natural to a native speaker in this exact context? |
3 Answers
Explanation:
Use the following pattern for choosing between "historic" and "historical":
- Historic = important or famous in history; something with significant impact.
- Historical = related to history in general or to events from the past, without implying importance.
Examples:
- The old city hall is a historic building. (It is important in the city's history.)
- The museum displays historical paintings. (Paintings from the past are shown, not necessarily famous ones.)
Check Your Usage:
Try rewriting these sentences, using the correct word:
- The library hosts ___ lectures about ancient times.
- The mayor spoke at a ___ event celebrating independence.
Feedback:
If you want to show that a building played an important role in history, use "historic". If you mean it is simply from the past, use "historical".
Explanation:
To choose correctly, compare these closely related examples:
- St. Peter's Cathedral is a historic building. (The building itself was the site of key city events.)
- The museum has a historical costume collection. (The clothes are from past eras, regardless of their importance.)
Rule of Thumb:
- Use historic for something that made history or is significant.
- Use historical for things from the past, or about history in general.
Practice:
Switch the adjectives in the examples to see if the meaning fits. Notice how "The museum has a historic costume collection" suggests those costumes impacted history, which is probably not what you want.
Explanation:
Ask yourself: Is the building known for an important event? If yes, use historic. If you're just referring to age or something from history, use historical.
Examples:
- This theater is a historic monument. (Famous performances or events happened there.)
- They organize a historical reenactment every summer. (Event simulates something from the past, not necessarily famous.)
Try it Yourself:
Write two sentences: one about a building with a notable past (use "historic"), and one about items from a particular period (use "historical").
Self-Editing Tip:
After writing, ask: Is my noun important in history (historic), or just related to the past (historical)?
Want to answer this question? Log in or create an account.