Can someone explain how to use relative clauses? I'm not sure about 'who' vs 'which'
I'm writing a letter to my English-speaking friend, and I want to describe my teacher. Should I say 'My teacher, who is very kind, helps me a lot' or 'My teacher, which is very kind, helps me a lot'?
I'm confused about when to use 'who' and 'which' in these situations. Also, do I always need commas before and after the clause? I'd appreciate some examples to help me understand how relative clauses work!
Context:
I'm preparing for the B2 Cambridge exam and want to make my sentences more complex.
What to Know
| Question You Likely Still Have | Direct Answer | How To Apply It |
|---|---|---|
| What is the core rule for someone explain relative clauses? | Pattern: [Person] + who + [extra info] [Thing/animal] + which + [extra info] Examples: My neighbor, who is very friendly, always says hello. | Example correction: My friend, which always helps me → My friend, who always helps me . |
| How do I apply someone explain relative clauses in a sentence like mine? | Relative clauses give extra information about a noun, and the word you choose depends on the noun type. | Practice suggestion: Write two sentences: one about a person you know, and one about your favorite object, using 'who' and 'which'. |
| What mistakes should I avoid with someone explain relative clauses? | Example correction: My friend, which always helps me → My friend, who always helps me . | Use 'who' for people, and 'which' for things or animals (not people). |
3 Answers
Relative clauses give extra information about a noun, and the word you choose depends on the noun type. Use 'who' for people, and 'which' for things or animals (not people).
Pattern:
- [Person] + who + [extra info]
- [Thing/animal] + which + [extra info]
Examples:
- My neighbor, who is very friendly, always says hello. (person)
- The book, which I finished yesterday, was excellent. (thing)
As for commas: use them to separate non-essential (extra) information. If the clause just gives extra detail, use commas. If it defines which person/thing you mean, don’t use commas.
Practice suggestion: Write two sentences: one about a person you know, and one about your favorite object, using 'who' and 'which'. Then check: did you use 'who' for a person? 'Which' for a thing?
Self-edit tip: If you write about a person and use 'which', quickly swap it for 'who'. Example correction: My friend, which always helps me → My friend, who always helps me.
Let's see how 'who' and 'which' operate by comparing similar sentences:
- The teacher who explains clearly is popular. (Correct: 'who' because 'teacher' is a person.)
- The classroom which has big windows is bright. (Correct: 'which' because 'classroom' is a thing.)
Notice:
- Use 'who' for people (teacher, friend, mother).
- Use 'which' for objects or animals (class, book, dog).
Commas: Use commas when the information is extra (not necessary to know who/what you mean).
- My teacher, who comes from Spain, is helpful. (Extra information – use commas)
- The student who arrives first gets the front seat. (Identifies which student – no commas)
Practice: Try pairing nouns with 'who' or 'which', e.g., 'My friend ___ likes music' and 'The chair ___ is broken', and fill in the blank with the correct word.
Correction practice: If you ever write 'a teacher which', change 'which' to 'who' – think: is it a person?
Think of 'who' as a connector for people and 'which' for things or animals. Ask yourself: Is the noun a person? Use 'who.' Is it a thing? Use 'which.'
Examples:
- My cousin, who lives in Canada, speaks three languages. ('who' = person)
- The film, which won an award, was directed by a famous actor. ('which' = thing)
Commas: If the clause is extra information, use commas. If it identifies the person or thing, no commas:
- The man who fixed my car did a great job. (Identifies – no commas)
- My car, which is ten years old, still works well. (Extra detail – with commas)
Guided practice: Write one sentence about a person and one about an object in your room. Then switch 'who' to 'which' (or vice versa) and notice if the meaning changes or becomes incorrect.
Correction: When you reread your sentences, underline the noun before the relative clause and decide: person = who, thing = which.
Want to answer this question? Log in or create an account.